NOT FRAGILE LIKE A FLOWER...LIKE A BOMB.
Feb. 17, 2026

The Fire Pit

The Fire Pit
The Fire Pit
Unspeakable: A True Crime Podcast By Kelly Jennings
The Fire Pit

On April 17th, 2011 Seath Jackson, a 15 year old, was murdered. The ensuing investigation rocked this community in Florida when his Ex-Girlfriend Amber Wright along with four others were charged with his murder.

Timestamps
08:07 Amber Wright
13:45 The Setting in Summerfield
19:28 The Missing Person Report
20:14 A Disturbing Confession
42:06 The Weight of Guilt
1:01:04 A Love Triangle Emerges

0:06 Welcome to Unspeakable, a true crime podcast where I tell stories of real crimes with real victims, whose cases are so shocking that many are left wondering how is this even real? I use my experiences in law enforcement corrections, and combined with my years as a criminal justice educator, dig deep into complex cases of evil acts, some so evil many feel they are unspeakable. Warning. Unspeakable as intended for mature audiences. If you are easily offended, then I'm not your girl. Listening discretion is advised. Hey, y'all, it's kJ.

0:59 He're back with another episode of Unspeakable. My people in the South, have you been partying? Because it is Marty gral time down here, and I spent Saturday having the time of my life. I know it was Valentine's Day. I also know the LSU women's basketball team was taken on South Carolina, but my butt was in New Orleans catching beads and having a blast. So for the people who aren't down here, I feel sorry for you. It's a great time. But go look at my Patreon. I've posted some pictures on there so you can check it out and see what Marty girls like down here. If you're interested. And before I start the episode, I've got some shout outs. I've got to get him out there. And I'm going to West Des Moines, Iowa. And this is where Carrie. Now I've never had this last name before.

1:42 I think it's is Brand or Isa Brand. Carrie is a brand from Iowa. How are you, Carrie. I'm so glad to have you. Thank you so much for joining. And then we're gonna jump over to Davenport, Florida, and this is where mister Richard Staley is. Hi, Richard, thank you for joining. I'm actually gonna be in Florida this episode, so you might be familiar with the places that I'm talking about. And then McGregor, Texas, Miss Amy, Derek, Hi Amy, how are things over there in Texas? And then Norman, Oklahoma, Elizabeth Paxton, what is going on? Elizabeth? I hope things are wonderful over there in Oklahoma. And then we're gonna jump to California where we have new Men, California where Melinda Hastings is located. So we have been all over how are you, Melinda? From Iowa to Texas to California.

2:31 We're all over the place. But I'm thankful to have each and every one of you in my crime family. Y'all are making my dreams come true and I'm just having the time of my life. So hopefully you're also listening in on my Derek Todd Lee series. We've got some more epic episodes come in your way. And then this episode is gonna be one of my regular ones, and we're gonna be in Summerfield, Florida. So I guess I'm gonna have to ask Richard to reach out to me. Richard is Davenport near Summerfield. I have no idea, so maybe you can let me know, but we're going to go to Summerfield, Florida. And this is located in the upper middle portion of the Panhandle, just to give us a little bit of a grasp of where this is, and it's an unincorporated community of Marion County. Now the county itself, I found out, is the self proclaimed horse capital of the world and they have thoroughbred farms all throughout.

3:24 I actually did not know that my aunt breeds horses like this, and so I never, I guess, thought about Florida breeding a lot of horses over there. But either way, outdoorsy people in general, they would love this area. Tons of activities and attractions in the great outdoors. I saw everything from ziplining over the waterways to touring the lakes and glass bottom boats, and it just is an area that continues to draw in people from all over year after year. But to the locals, and I would say that I'm guilty of this too where I'm from. To the locals, it's just another day in Florida. They're used to this, just like down here, Marty Girl, that's a thing that we do. I mean, my niece moved off to Texas, and I could not believe how shook us I was when they didn't get a Marty Girl break.

4:11 What what do you mean? You don't get a break to go party and catch beads? That's crazy. But in Florida, the teenagers there, you know that they're not gonna be ones to go likely take in all of the beautiful scenery. They're probably gonna take it for granted. And how much amazing, how many amazing things there are to do to do there. The surroundings can be beautiful and one of a kind compared to other places around the country. But there were two local teens there who were far less focused on the scenery and much more laser focused on each other. And these kids both happen to be fifteen years old, and I think when you're telling a story from the perspective of the people that lived it, you have to put yourself in their shoes. Remember being fifteen years old, you're a coming of age at that point, You're hormones are racing, You're interested sexually in the either opposite sex at this time. You know, we can say same sex whatever.

5:08 You're just interested in other people and trying to find a partner or someone to do life with. And two of these kids were Seth Jackson and Amber Wright, and they were both from Okala. Now, both of these teams, as you can imagine, they were newer to relationships as young people are, and they were in more of that short term dating world. Although kids will often claim that you know they're in a relationship, it'll last a week or two, maybe even three, and then they've moved on, broken up. It's traumatic, and they've moved on to their next love interest. We all know about this. But Seth and Amber guys, they felt that they were in a long termer here because they had been dating almost three whole months. That's right. This is a long term relationship for a fifteen year old. Now, Amber, she was your typical ninth grader. I would say she had her hair dyed a new color every few weeks. She was trying her hardest to be edgy and cool and popular. She would, you know, often straighten her hair like us curly gals do, but her hair was naturally red and curly, and it just wasn't. You can tell if you have curly hair, I'm telling you right now, you can tell when someone straightens their hair and it's not their natural look. Now, her upbringing, I'm gonna tell you it left a lot to be desired because I personally feel like she was allowed to do things that I was never allowed to do at that age, nor would I allow my own children to do at that age. Things like she already

6:40 had multiple lip piercings, she had her eyebrow pierced, and remember she's only fifteen years old, but she also already has tattoos. Now, I know, different strokes different folks. I have a very very good friend who last week took his daughter who is fifteen years old, and they got tattoos together, you do you. I'm not judging here. People think I'm being mean and judgy. I'm not. I just think that we all look at life and at stories through the lens of our own perspective, and so that's how we judge, and we weigh and we decide what is acceptable and what is not. So in her life, she was allowed a lot more freedoms than I was at that age. She had those tattoos, one for certain, she had a bear that was on like her lower lower right hip, and she kind of was allowed to have way more freedoms than I would think the average kid her age would. But all of that aside, she still looked like a little girl. She was pale, she had freckles all over her face, and with that curly, wild red hair. She genuinely reminds me of Meredith from that cartoon Brave. Do you remember that movie? She has that vibe going on. But she had met her match, it seemed in young Seth, because he too lived this life a bit on the wild side. And I say this because both of the parenting styles of these two children seemed to be a bit more permissive than the average home. Now you can tell me if you think I'm wrong, y'all can write me and let me know if I'm way off kilter here. That's my opinion of

8:11 what I saw when I was researching this case. But regardless of that, they were very loved kids by their parents, and their parents were doing their best to try to raise children in what seemed to be lower to lower middle class homes. Their relationship together was one of those live, fast and free type of relationships. So very early on, these younger kids were starting to have sex with one another. They were even dabbling in drugs together. Now, my opinion of this was the drug of choice here was probably going to be marijuana. When I think of young kids and them dabbling, that's what my mind goes to. But I was pretty surprised to find out that they were not just dabbling in weed. I mean, they were also trying cocaine, which I felt was an obviously concerning red flag for people that young. Now, obviously they weren't just running home and being like, hey, mom did a line of coke earlier. Okay, they were lying to their parents about the times that they were out and they were up to no good. But once they were in the sight of adults they would rein it in, so they would go out and they would do the dumb teenager things.

9:20 Make poor decisions, no doubt, but in front of the adults and their parents, they were trying to keep it a little more kosher. Now, the area where the kids had grown up was one where the families there seemed to have grown up generationally in that area, so it was a place where the kids could run free, and it seemed like everybody kind of knew one another over long periods of time, and so it felt like it was pretty safe where they were. Now, this is again my opinion, but based in research, but there genuinely seemed to be a lack of supervision over these kids, and as such, they would hang around people older than them, with act says to more freedoms than a teen would probably need to have. So, for example, I'm not a fan of young teens being friendly with people who are like older teens but married with their own homes. Hopefully you all are well adjusted. And you know why I'm saying this, because we know what's gonna happen when young teens go off to homes of other younger or older teens but still young and they're married at eight seventeen and eighteen, and they're put under a roof that they're supposed to manage. I mean, they're gonna do things that teenagers do and they're not gonna be called out for it.

10:39 Fifteen year olds up in an eighteen year old's house are gonna go off into other bedrooms for privacy, and then nine months later we're gonna have more babies being born to these teens. Okay, I digress, but you'll see why I'm saying this. I think it becomes very important in this story to recognize that before we dive in, that those kinds of things are what we're going on. It turns out that there's going to be a whole friend group here who I'm going to slowly introduce you to throughout the story. And this is going to include Amber's older brother, Kyle Hooper. Now, Kyle was just a year older than Amber, and they both shared that red orange hair and these freckles and a mother, but they had different fathers, so they were really half brothers and sister.

11:23 But that was her brother so to speak. So Kyle and Seth were friends and the trio would hang out together as a group and they would often go and hang out together at eighteen year old Charlie e Lely's house. Now, Charlie is a female. I just want to make sure I'm clear on that so it doesn't get confusing as I'm introducing people to this story. So Charlie e Lee is a female, and she is eighteen years old at the point of the story. There's Seth who's dating Amber. They're both fifteen. And then there is Amber's brother Kyle, who is sixteen. So there's four players right now that I'm trying to introduce you to. And like I mentioned, Charlie was older than these other kids by just a couple of years, but she had access to her own home because she was a very very young, married woman.

12:14 And Charlie's life it had been way less than a fairy tale story. She was raised in Maryland by her aunt Lisa, who got custody of her when she was seven years old. Now, to me, this tells me a lot about the family dynamic. Although I did not go down the rabbit hole to figure out why she was with her aunt at just seven years old, I'm sure we can assume that's because there was either a parenting issue or something along those lines that someone else needed to have custody of her. Well, about a year before this story starts to unfold, Charlie had moved to Florida in an attempt to reconnect with her biological mother. Again, That's why I said her life wasn't you know, exactly a bed of roses here because her biological mother didn't even raise her. So when she moved to Florida to go try to reconnect with her mother, at the same time, she found herself lonely, and she found herself searching for love, which she turned to the online methods of meeting people.

13:17 And when she got online, she would go and she would meet a guy named Joseph Burham or Burham however you prefer to pronounce that. Now, long story short, They quickly fell in love and Charlie moved to the Summerfield area to be with him, and they soon after got married. Now, this resulted in them living together in a small trailer that was just a few miles down the road from Seth's home, and over time they all became friends. Now, Charlie's new husband, I'm going to tell you, was not exactly a knight in shining armor that was going to give her this fairy tale romance, because just very shortly into their relationship, he would be sentenced to prison. So off goes and this left Charlie at home alone. She found herself lonely, and she was also financially struggling in a big way. She was struggling to just pay the rent on the trailer by herself. So to ward off this loneliness, she would invite people to come over and to stay with her. And this included these teenagers that she befriended in the neighborhood. So, looking back on Charlie's life, I'm going to tell you this, she wasn't exactly a popular kid in life growing up. And one of the biggest hang ups that she found was that she was often teased about being legally blind in one of her eyes.

14:40 And it was very obvious that there was an issue with one of her eyes. It wanders off to the right and you can tell that there is a medical issue with that eye. But here now in Florida, she felt like she had made good friends because this would be evidenced by the fact that there were always teenagers at her home. Now they would come and go, they would hang out there. As an adult looking at this, one would likely argue that they were just hanging out there because there was a lack of supervision. But to Amber, she felt like these were her friends and that's why they wanted to be there. So as the weeks passed, Amber and Seth, the two fifteen year olds that are dating, their relationship would prove itself to be one of those tumultuous ones that's filled with typical fifteen year old bullshit.

15:27 There was jealousy, fighting, sex, drugs, all of the things that young people have no clue how to mitigate the young in their young age, and so they would do the typical be mean to one another, then make up, have sex. Things would be fun for a while, and then they would break up and just then they would try to go on and make each other jealous and all of that. Bs. Yes, it was one of those dramatic relationships unfolding before everyone's eyes. But Seth really did care about Amber, even though they were breaking up and it was getting kind of wild, He really did care about her so much so that he would even talk to his mama about the drama. And this was obviously to a limited extent. Because that's his mother and he's fifteen.

16:14 But his mother would then give him some truths that kids that age don't want to hear, things like she's not going to be the only girlfriend in your lifetime. Son, These girls come and go. You're young, there's lots of fish out there in the sea. Blah blah blah blah blah. Great advice, but Seth didn't want to hear it. No, I love her, She's the love of my life. For the last three months now. Seth and his mama were close, so I don't want to downgrade that or anything. But even though he seemed to be a bit wild, both of his parents were very invested in his life and they loved him dearly. I don't want that to be mistaken or misconstrued. There wild, but loved. So Seth was known to go out and do his thing, but he would always check in with his mama always, and so that's why on the evening of April seventeenth of twenty eleven, when Seth wasn't returning his mother's calls nor her texts, and then he didn't come home, she became extremely alarmed, very alarmed, as I think any of us would be.

17:20 No matter what that boy was doing, he would always answer his mama. But that evening he was not, So she tried to contact him all throughout the night. She texted, she called, she tried to locate where he was. She did this to no avail. But when the next day rolled around and daybreak broke and that boy still had not called her back or shown up, the anger that she may have felt for him not doing what he was supposed to do, and then combined with the fear it now had transitioned into complete distress. And so she called the Marion County Sheriff's office and she said, look, my son is missing. I need help. This is not like him. So, due to his age, a missing person's report was immediately filed. But while that is the case, I'm gonna shoot you straight here. Investigators were kind of looking at the totality of circumstances here and the fact that he was a bit of a rebellious one, and they wondered if this was really a missing person or if this was more of a runaway situation where the boy didn't want to be under his parents roof and ran off to go do whatever. So regardless of whatever their thoughts may have been. At that time, the investigators dug in and they began their investigation into his whereabouts, genuinely assuming that they were going to find him somewhere and bring him home. So what they did is what we always know that they're going to do. They started with his innermost circle and they worked their way out. Now, the fact here is that there had been no cell phone activity by Seth. That there that's alarming. It's not

18:55 an end all, be all, but that's alarming because kids are gonna be on these devices, even if they're not talking to their parents, even if they're ignoring their parents, because they're doing whatever they want to go do, they're gonna be on those devices. So that was a red flag. Investigators decided to throw together a list of friends and places he would frequent, and they wanted to set out and look for these people and speak to these people. This is very typical things to do. But all in all, Seth was nowhere to be found, Like nowhere poof Gone disappeared the day after Seth was reported missing, So a whole nother day has gone by. It's been two days now.

19:36 A tip would come in to the police regarding Seth's whereabouts or lack thereof, And this tip seemed to be a pretty big one. So Seth's girlfriend, Amber, her mother is the one that called police with what seemed to be a bit of horrifying information. Amber's brother that's also her son, right, had told her mom, we got to talk. I witnessed something that may explain why nobody can find Seth. So obviously police are like, oh my gosh, come down here right now. We need to talk to you. This could be something that we really need information on. And so Amber's mother brought her brother down there to talk to police. And his name was Kyle. Now he is a miner. I want to let you know that. And so his mother stayed in the room and accompanied him during this questioning because she already knew the story anyway, and she just wanted to be there to help support her son. Now, Kyle, let's talk about Kyle. Kyle's a bigger kid. Okay, he's a big dude. He's solid. I told you he looks like Amber. But I want to make sure you know Amber, is this itdybdy petite little thing.

20:48 This boy is solid. He's like two hundred and thirty pounds. Okay, he was young, but police would quickly find out that he was also somewhat on his own, even though he still leaned on his mama a bit. At sixteen years old, he was already moved out and he was living with that Charlie Eally that I mentioned to you. Now, they were not in a sexual relationship. It was a roommate type situation. Remember, Charlie was struggling because her husband went to prison. She had to pay the rent, so having people move in was helpful to her. Now, there was also another guy that was living at the house with them as well, and they just referred to him as Roach. Y'all, I do not like roaches. I know that's not what this is. But just the name Roach grosses me out to no avail roaches scare me. Tornadoes and roaches, no thank you can't do it now. His real name was justin Sodo, okay, and he was another roommate of sorts in this house. But if I say Roach, that's what I'm talking about now. During the questioning that was going on, you could tell that Kyle's mother was in distress. Okay, she was calm, but she was in distress. She kept one hand on his leg, and whenever he would get animated or worked up while he was giving up this information, you would see her kind of just tap him on the leg, almost like calm down, Okay, it's ever so slight, but you can see it happening. She was very distressed,

22:20 and I can't imagine being a mother bringing your child in to talk to police about what this kid is about to tell them. But she did the right thing, and I'm grateful that she did that. But what Kyle had to say was, at some points it was wild. It would become disjointed, and then he would kind of just throw out stuff like word vomit, and this detective had to work really hard to kind of piece it together because this fifteen year or sixteen year old was kind of all over the place. But from the jump, Kyle told the investigator that not only did he know that something had happened to Seth, but he knew who did it. So this of course was like, wow, it's not usual that easy, right, but there it was, And Kyle jumped right in and just started talking just from the top. He of course knew Seth because Seth was dating his little sister Amber, and there was another friend that he mentioned in this story. And this guy's name is gonna be Michael. Sometimes he referred to him as Mike, but that's the same guy. Now, Mike, let's talk about him for a minute. Mike had a warrant out for his arrest and Seth Amber's boyfriend was wanting to fight Michael.

23:34 Now at this moment in time, it was rather unclear why, but there was beef going on between Seth and this guy Michael. But Seth, Seth was adamant, according to Kyle, that he wanted to fight Mike. And this was just a few days before Seth had gone missing, that he was wanting to fight Mike. Now, Seth had come over to the house that Charlie ially owned on a bicycle at some point, and he said that words were exchanged between Seth and Mike. Now, when I say words exchanged, I really kind of mean that Seth was outside running his mouth, according to Kyle, and Mike was inside of the house. Seth was also in a group of other teenagers and Kyle was like, I don't know who all they were exactly, but I did know Seth and they were in essence harassing this guy Mike. And telling him to come outside and to fight. But Mike did not want to go outside. He did not want to go outside.

24:33 He did not want to fight, Seth. So let me tell you a little bit more about Mike so you can really grasp what's going on here. Mike or Michael is Michael Bargo And from the start, he, I will tell you, is a misfit, a misfit at minimum. So he was originally from Michigan, but after his parents' divorce, he kind of was flip flopping back and forth. He lived with his mother and then he made his way to Florida, and then at the moment that I'm telling you this story, he was staying at Charlie Ely's trailer. And he didn't have much of a very good behavioral history.

25:15 And I want to break that down for you. So Mike was wild, Okay. He had been thrown out of school, out of high school and all that for fighting. He had been sent to an alternative school, like a disciplinary school, and he did not seem to do much better there. And I want to stop and tell you this, as a teacher with experience kids that are fighting and acting out in a regular school campus, I would probably give this number of ninety percent. Ninety percent of the time, it is a lack of structure at home that causes a lot of these issues in the schools because they don't want to follow the rules because they don't follow rules at home. But then once you get him into these behavioral disciplinary schools where it's a lot tougher and where I am locally, the teachers are loving, no doubt, but it's more of militaristic and it's more of like they dress in military looking clothing and their instructors are like drill sergeants nine times out of ten, y'all. When they transition there and they realize that structure is a good thing, but they have to kind of force it into these knuckleheads, they do well, they tend to excel, and a lot of these kids that are total behavioral issues in regular schools become likable at these other schools because the structure is what they need, but they have to learn it in a harder manner. So whenever Mike transition to these schools, it just didn't take. Man, it didn't take. He was not that kid. He hated authority,

26:47 and the other problem of that was that he wasn't afraid of authority either. He's not afraid at all of authority. He used drugs while he was on campus. He would not go to class. He was just a high ass mess. And to be frank with you, he's the kind of kid that everybody looks at eventually and goes that dude's gonna end up in prison. Nothing you say or do gets through to this kid. Matter of fact, he had also spent time in juvie. And I'll tell you he's not the type of kid most people would want around their home hanging around their kids. Now. He was very skinny, little dude. He was the proverbial wanna be thug, but wanna be had now transitioned into more of a was a thug. Okay, he had transitioned. He was there. Well, Seth was wanting to fight Mike, but Mike was trying to avoid the fight. He didn't want to fight Seth.

27:42 So Seth had at that point, according to Kyle, started blowing up Amber's phone, his little sister, and was like wanting to talk to her and wanting her to come outside, YadA, YadA, YadA. Well, at some point he said that Seth came into the trailer wanting to talk to Amber. Charlie had let him in, and Charlie didn't realize that there was this beef and all of this stuff going on. Well, realizing that Seth was now inside of the trailer where Kyle, although sixteen year old, was still paying rent there, he wasn't having it. Kyle already had beef with Seth himself. Why because Seth and his little sister Amber had recently broken up. Seth broke up with Amber. Now because of all of this drama, I'm about to just jump in two legs deep, like Kyle did at this point in the interview. But he says, at that point they had words. Okay, not only did they have words, but there was He said it was a stick, but it was more of like a piece of lumber that had broken off of like a doorcasing. Okay, but he picked up that piece of doorcasing and he went over and he just smoked Seth in the head with it. Bow just hit him over the head with it.

28:58 Seth became dazed by this. He kind of stumbled backwards. And I don't know if Seth was stumbling back or if he was more of like trying to get away, but he went towards the kitchen area of this trailer, which was very close proximity to that living room where he had just walked in. Now, either way, he was making distance from Kyle. So as Kyle just smoked this kid over the head, he starts yelling at Seth and says, get the fuck out of my house. Get the fuck out of my house, and do not come back. He was the older brother. He was defending his sister against this other boy that had broken up with his little sister. Now, as these words are being exchanged, this is where shit gets crazy, because out of nowhere, out of a side bedroom, Kyle said that Michael Bargo threw the door open and burst into the kitchen. Not only that it was without warning, and Michael Bargo had a gun on him that he just pulled straight up and not even aware in any way, shape or form of what the drama was all about, he didn't ask any questions. Michael raised that gun and began unloading this pistol into a fifteen year old boy.

30:19 Bow bow bow bow Bow, just kept pulling the trigger, the trigger. So Kyle is in shock at this moment. Sure, yeah, he was wanting to fight Seth. There's no doubt here he wanted to hit him over the head with the damn board. That's what the kid wanted to do. The sixteen year old wanted to hit the fifteen year old. But he just now saw Seth eat eight bullets is how he thought it was eight bullets right in front of his eyes. He was horrified at this. He like kind of stumbled back in shock. He couldn't believe what he had just witnessed, and he did not know what to do because this was nowhere near what he expected to happen. In that moment, he almost was like, did this really just happen? He was in a daze. Fighting is one thing, but this, when it is all broken down, this just turned into something he was not prepared for.

31:08 A sixteen year old boy just saw a fifteen year old boy shot multiple times right in front of him and then collapse. Now in the shock of this all, his little sister Amber and the homeowner, Charlie. They had been in I believe Charlie's bedroom at this point, so they had come out hearing the gunshots. Think about how loud that had to be. They came running out. They did not know what was going on. They see Michael with the pistol. Holy shit. They turn around and they go running, scared out of their ever loving minds back into the bedroom and they go back and they lock the door. Now, in that moment, Kyle did not know what to do. You know, everybody wants to be bad until people start bullets start flying. Okay, So Kyle didn't know what to do. He's looking at Seth standing there literally with a i'moking gun, and I cannot I just keep going back to what I must that have sounded like inside of a trailer, having bullets go off in such close close proximity like that, one after the other.

32:10 So Kyle just tears out, running through the front door because his mind was racing. He doesn't know what the hell to do. He sees Michael do this, and he knew that Michael was known to have a gun on him. Okay, Michael was known to carry a twenty two revolver, which, as he's telling the story, it makes total sense because the revolver can hold you know, six eight bullets whatever. So this is whatever that cylinder had, he seemed to have unloaded it into this kit. So Kyle goes outside he's like freaking out, doesn't know what to do. He starts like trying to calm down, get a grip of himself, and figure out, my god, my sister is still in that trailer. I don't know what to do. So after he gets calm he goes back up to the door and kind of timidly but efficiently, he opens the door to go back inside of the trailer. But when he opened the door, things just got worse because he looks in front of him and he sees Mike now dragging the mortally wounded Seth towards the bathroom. So he's standing in the doorway deer in the headlights, has never experienced something like this in his life, doesn't know what to do.

33:21 And that's when Michael Bargo kind of started barking orders. He was waving the gun around wildly. He was yelling, and he said that if anybody said a fucking word, they were gonna get shot too. He then yelled out, and by he, I mean Michael Bargo then yelled out towards the girls that were in that back bedroom and said you better stay back there. If you come back out, there's gonna be two more bodies in this trailer, So Kyle is going to do basically what he doesn't want to do, anything to make Michael freak out even more. So. There was a couch kind of on a back wall right there in that living room, and he kind of just sat down on the couch and is just keeping his eyes locked on Seth. He didn't know what he could do or what he couldn't do, but he didn't want to get shot himself, and he feared that his sister would get shot too. Now, during this whole episode, Mike was becoming more and more unhinged. He started yelling about how he was gonna have eight bodies by the end of the week, and he started spewing out these names of girls and people that Kyle wasn't quite sure of what he was saying, so he was screaming out names like Tessa and Chris and how he was going to do something to somebody's dad. But he was all over the place with this rant, and he added to that, look, I'm already a convicted felon, so what does it matter at this point. A fucking shot this dude. I'm already fell and I'm going to prison. My life's over. It does not even matter now, this gun claim at this point while they're talking, it does check out because, like

34:55 I told you, Kyle's mother was in during this questioning, and Kyle's mother knew Michael pretty well. So just the day before, if I'm not mistaken, I believe that Mike's dad had grown up with Amber and Kyle's mom. So I think they kind of go way back, that generational thing that I spoke about. Don't quote me on that, but I'm pretty sure that's true now. Just days prior to Seth going missing, Okay, and before her son had even admitted anything to her that he had seen Seth shoot and seen Mike shoot Seth, Mike had shown up, I guess at their house and they were just kind of talking and Mike asked the mom, Hey, would you still love me if I did something wrong? Now, Mike, he actually called Kyle's mama mom. It was like an endearing way, and so she's like, well, hey, man, you know what did you do? Why would you ask me that?

35:53 And he's like, Mom, just tell me if I did something wrong, would you still love me? And she's like, well, yeah, man, I'd love you. But she knew Mike to be knucklehead kid, and she's like, tell me what's going on here, dude, Like what is happening? And that's when Mike had explained to her that there was a guy mad at him because he bought a gun from this guy, but he never went and had the gun re registered in his own name, Mike and Mike's own name. So she's like, well, why don't you just go get the gun registered in your name, dude, And he says, well, I can't because I'm a convicted felon. Now, at that point, one would think you'd say, well, why do you have the gun, dude, Like you're a felon, you're not supposed to have it.

36:33 Felon in possession of a firearm is not allowed. But instead Mom just kind of shrugged it off and she just looked at him was like, dude, you know, why don't you just do the right thing and quit getting in the middle of all this chaos, quit making dumb decisions. Again. I want to express here that I feel like these parents aren't bad people, but they're just more violent permissive in their parenting styles, and they overlooked things that the average parent would not. For example, Mike's dad, the one that I think grew up with the mom here. His name was also Mike, so I'm going to refer to him as Mike Senior. Mike Sior knew that his son had that gun, but he never said anything about it.

37:15 So you know, your son's getting in all this trouble, but you're going to just overlook the fact that he's carrying around a pistol. I just want you to know this. And Mike's Senior, with his son Mike Junior, both had lived with the grandmother after his parents' divorce. So the whole family dynamic here just seems to be a hot ass mess with low income and poor decision making all around. So Kyle and Amber's mom just kind of looked at Mike in that moment, and she's looking at him, thinking, this dude is just ridiculous. You know, this is a ridiculous teenager. And she wrote it off as him just trying to look tough and try to get negative attention basically from her. But that same day, that same day that they were have that discussion and they were talking about his gun, he also mentioned to her that he had burned a bunch of stuff that he needed to get rid of, but he kept making a big deal of about all of this burning stuff. Now Mom is telling the investigator this in the police station. That's why I'm bringing it all up in this order. And she said, look, dude, you know you keep bringing up all this stuff, but I don't understand why you're making such a big deal about burning stuff. And that's when he she asked him, why are you so freaked out about freaked out about all the stuff that you're burning and he said, oh, I can't tell you that because it's evidence. So she kind of like turns around at him and she's like, what, what do you mean it's evidence? So she kept kind of pushing him, like what do you mean it's evidence, And that's when he finally explained, Look, I had to burn a bunch of my marijuana and a bunch of

38:47 my paraphernalia. I had to get rid of it. And so by this point, Mom's frustrated, She's irritated with this juvenile bullshit. She doesn't want to hear it anymore. She's like, look, dude, I'm busy, like make better decisions and go do your thing. Go be okay. But the following morning, after all of those discussions. That's when she realized that Seth was missing and Seth was dating her daughter, right, And so she started thinking back about these conversations and it occurred to her, oh my god, was Mike Junior trying to like confess something to me because he said he did something wrong. Well, she knew that Mike Junior was staying at the trailer with her son Kyle. So she goes and she confronts Kyle and she says, Kyle, what wall was being burned at the trailer? I want to know what's going on here.

39:36 This is weird. Seth is missing and now all this stuff was being burned. What all was Mike talking about? Oh my god, was he trying to confess something to me? And that is when her son, Kyle, admitted everything to her and that is why she had called police. That's how all of this kind of unraveled. So Kyle back to him. He continues to explain, I was on EDG all night. I was unable to sleep. He lived at the trailer, so he didn't leave and I'm like, no, wonder dude, of course you're on edge. And that's when his mother pipes up and says, you know, That's when I realized that my kids are not understanding how big this is. This isn't something that we can just not address, and we have got to call the police. And that is when I called the police. So the detective is taking all of this in right, She's listening, she's watching Mom, she's watching Kyle explain everything. Mom's cell phone goes off a couple of times during this interview and it's Kyle's dad calling, and she's trying to update him on Oh my god, you know this is horrible, our kids saw this murder blah blah blah. Well, the detective asks, Mom, look, do you think you could step out for just a minute, would you mind if I talked to Kyle alone? And Mom is like, absolutely, do what you gotta do. I already know the story. Yes. So Mom leaves the room, I guess, and goes and talks to dad on the phone, and the detective leans in and she's like, all right, man, look, let's talk like one on one. Your mother's not here.

41:04 I genuinely feel like there is more here that you're not telling me, and you know, I feel like you've got to come out with this. So Kyle's behavior looks defeated at this point, and he looks up at her and he's like, look, there's something I want to tell you, but I cannot tell my mom. I mean, she will die. She will just die. And you can't just tell your mom these things. The detective obviously understood this and was like, Okay, look, this is just between me and you. You can share this with your mother on your own time, at your own pace. But I need to know everything because we're trying to find Seth and we can't have him missing. So Kyle took a deep breath and he said, okay, look, when I went back into the trailer, everything I said is true. I was terrified. I could not believe what I was seeing. But Mike he asked me to help him move Seth's body, and I had to. I had to.

41:59 I had no choice. But I can't tell my mom that. I can't tell my mom I was helping move a dead body. Do you know what I mean? That'll killer. I can't say that. So let's stop for a second here, and I want to tell you something. You may already know this and that's fine, but if you don't, I do want to give you a little bit of education here, And I want to ask you this question to start, have you ever watched football? Have you ever actually watched a football game when the announcers they get all excited, they get all up in their all up in their feelings, and they're talking about the quarterback. Oh, he's been flushed out of the protective pocket that he's in. And then he's looking, he's looking, there's no one to throw to, and he says, oh, he had to rush. He was under a great deal of duress. And he throws that ball out to the sidelines. So in criminal law this will matter, Okay. So this is why all of this I want to explain to you, Because duress means that people do things under pressure that they otherwise would not want to do. Okay. And so there's an example here if there's like, there's elements to duress that you have to prove in order for it to make sense. And I want want you to compare and contrast what I'm saying here, and you tell me if you think that this kid was under duress. Number one is that there's got to be an immediate threat of imminent or impending danger if they do not comply. Kyle was standing there with another guy with a gun he just watched unload it into another kid. Do you think that there was imminent danger? Check mark? I do. Number two, there's got to be a threat of serious harm or even death, and that's why they comply with this person's demands. Check mark.

43:31 He just watched him murder somebody. Of course there's a threat there. There's also got to be no reasonable alternative to the actions that they take. The person doesn't have the opportunity to escape or avoid the threat. Now, someone right now is going to say, well, hell, he could have ran out of the trailer. Yes, he could have, But you also have to look at the complexity of he's sixteen years old, okay, and he's seeing a guy murdered, and the guy's got a gun, and he's saying he's going to get eight bodies underneath his belt. Do you think that it was reasonable for him to say, well, I think I'll check out at this point. No, that's why he stayed. And then the last one amongst others, though, is that there's got to be a reasonable belief that the person felt that the threat would be carried out if they don't help. And this guy, Mike had just said, if your sisters come out, there's gonna be or your sister and her friend come out, there's going to be two more bodies. And he was going to kill and he wanted eight people dead by the end of the week.

44:23 That is why it is so important that I feel you understand dress. And of course he didn't leave, but he didn't want to say this in front of his mother because he knew how terrible it sounded. So I would argue in this moment, Kyle was feeling just this. Mike had a gun, he had just murdered someone in front of him, and the kid said, help me, or there will be more bodies. He threatened him. Obviously Kyle complied. So what did he do? He said, Look, I helped Carrie Seth's bleeding body outside into the backyard where Mike had a fire pit going. Now, this was a normal activity. They had already established this. It's something that they always did just to pass they didn't have a lot of money. They could go out back, sit around the bonfire, drink, smoke, make out, whatever, but that was kind of what they did.

45:07 But this time Mike stoked up that fire because he wanted to burn Seth's body. So he helped Mike put Seth's body into a sleeping bag that they found in the trailer, and then they carried him outside to the fire. Now, once out there, Kyle said, look, I helped place him on this big fire. I did, but at that point I could not do anymore. I was sick. And I told him, dude, I can't do this. I can't do anymore. You do you, but I can't watch this. This is this is outside of my scope of what I can You know what I can take. And Mike and him had a short discussion, and Mike said, all right, Brah, look, I'm gonna let you go, but there is one fucking condition.

45:48 You better not ever say a word. Look at him, and then look at me. You better not say another word. Kyle swore himself to secrecy before he returned back into the trailer. At that point, Amber and Charlie were now kind of peeking out of the bedroom and coming out, going what is happening? What is going on? And Kyle screamed at them, go back into the room, shut the door, do not come out, do not come out, Just staying there for the rest of the night. I don't give a shit, just don't come out. And the girls, terrified that Kyle's reaction, did just that, they went back into the room and they stayed there. Kyle, who went back into the other where his bedroom was, went into the bathroom. He showered off. He was mortified by what had just happened.

46:31 He took a shower, and then he pretty much remained in his bedroom the rest of the night. But while all this is going on, his mind was racing, and his mind was going back to the last couple of weeks and time that he had spent with Mike Junior, and the fact that he had come home a couple of times from work. He worked at a McDonald's. Okay, he didn't have this high paying job, ornything. But when he had come home a few times Mike was staying there at the trailer, he found Mike and an extremely bad mental state. And he's thinking back on this, going, how did I not see that this guy was out of control? You know now, the reason that he found Mike in a bad state, Let's talk about it. He said that Mike had that warrant out for his arrest, and it was something that he had been dodging. The police over. That's why he was kind of hiding out in this trailer. And let's talk about what this warrant was for. Mike had gotten tied up with a chick that he really really cared about. He was all about this young girl. Okay, he loved her, he professed his love for her, but there was one huge issue here.

47:36 Mike was eighteen years old his love. How old was she? Well, I'm going to answer that question for you. She was in the thirteen to fourteen year old range. Yeah, Mike had been busted by her parents having sex with her. Obviously, she's much too young for him to be sleeping with. And we can all agree we understand why this was huge and that her parents were going to press charges against him for this sexual connection and activity. So the police were after him, and as far as he knew it, his life was over. He was going to be charged for having sex with this young girl. And because of this, Kyle had come home a few times in the last few weeks and found Mike with that very gun to his own head. This freaked him out, y'all. All of this was going on and Mike was saying he wanted to commit suicide. He said, it doesn't matter if I live or die. My life is over anyway. And Kyle was freaked out by this, but he always tried to talk him down. It was very stressful. He said one of the times when he went into the room or saw Mike with the gun to his head that as Kyle approached him closer, he picked the gun up and put it in his mouth and said, one more step, one more steven them up, pulled the trigger right in front of you. So Kyle had had backed off, but it was very obvious that this guy was in the throes of a breakdown, and now Mike had just ordered someone.

49:01 And the unhinged nature and volatility of this guy and what he was showing now was scary a shit, and I think we could all understand this. He was definitely capable of murder. He had just proved it. And during those weeks though, when he was trying to talk Mike down, Mike had told him about the fact that he might need to kill the family of this young girl to avoid going to prison because of that charge. He was hiding out over that warrant, and he even went into detail with Kyle about how he thought he could get away with it. This included if I shoot someone, I could put them in a sleeping bag or a blanket or whatever and then carry them out and burn them, burn them down to a chris basically cremate them, and when the bodies no more, no one will ever know.

49:52 That's the easiest way to get rid of it. And now it seemed that Mike was doing just that, but with Seth. So so the question of the detective and mine as well at this point was, Okay, why was Mike not wanting to fight Seth? And why was Seth there wanting to fight Mike? Okay, what was going on here? And it all went back to that warrant that Mike had. Seth knew about it, supposedly, I'm not sure. I can't confirm that or not. And that's why Seth was over there kind of agitating Mike and saying, why don't you come out, you know, trying to be tough and let's fight. In all of that, him and Amber had broken up, and but Mike couldn't because while Seth is doing all of this running of his mouth, if the police get called, they're gonna find Mike, right, So he doesn't want that to happen, but there was something else that was now explained to the detective. Kyle said that Seth had been beating up his little sister Amber. He said, he put hands on my sister, as people like to say. Amber had been very vocal about Seth hurting her and Seth So now Mike and Kyle had beef with their former friend over all of this. But Mike, being in that unstable mindset that he was in, it seemed like he had just snapped once Seth came inside of the trailer, and he just snapped and he shot him and he murdered him. Seth wanted to fight, but unfortunately he picked it with someone who was extremely unstable and it cost

51:22 him his life. Okay, I could see that happening. The detective was like, all right, I get all of this now, like putting these pieces together. I get what is going on here. Not that it should have happened, but it's understanding. But why was Seth at the house to begin with? Like, we're missing something here, Okay, what was this fight all about? How did this connection come to be? Well? Seth had been texting Amber that day about wanting to apologize and maybe work things out. He was blowing up Amber's phone wouldn't lebr alone. And here was that Amber was afraid to talk to him alone. Why because Seth had been beating her up. So she agreed that she would meet with him, and she wanted to go up the street to talk to him, but because she was scared, Charlie Eely, the girl that owns the trailer, agreed to go with her.

52:15 They were gone about an hour and then they went talked to Seth and then they came back to the house. But that's whenever Seth basically followed them back to the trailer and was adamant he wanted to talk to Amber Moore. Now, both Seth and Michael, of course, they hated one another at this point, and because of that warrant that was out for his arrest, and Seth was out there yelling and wanting to fight in the front yard and bringing about this extra agitation of Mike, who was trying to keep the low profile from the police. That is why it escalated the way that it did. So Kyle couldn't sleep that whole night. He goes back into that and he stayed at the trailer but throughout the night because he couldn't sleep. He kept peeking out, and he kept seeing that Mike was remaining outside and tending to this fire as he basically cremated fifteen year old Seth in the backyard. Now, by the next morning, Kyle wanted to distance himself from the trailer, and so he tried to go on like normal. He went to McDonald's, he worked his shift that's shown improven, and then when he got back to the trailer, he's kind of looking around because this is a lot okay to take in, and he noticed that there were spots of tan paint poured out in spots all over the backyard. Now the fire had died down at this point, he said, Seth's body was nowhere to be found, and he did know for a fact that that paint had not been poured out in the backyard the night before, so it stood out to him.

53:40 It caught his attention. The paint, by the way was tan colored, and he knew that that had to have been the paint from the trailer because Charlie and her husband had been repainting the trailer right before he was arrested and sent off to jail on whatever his charge was. Now, Mike was still at the trailer when Kyle had returned, and he saw all the paint and all this stuff going on. But he was frantic and he told Kyle, look, braul, I got to get out of town. Now, Kyle would have been lying if he said he wasn't relieved to the fact that Mike was now wanting to leave. Good, get your crazy ass out of here, because you're scaring everybody that's in this trailer. Getting a killer out of your house, that's a great idea. Now, Michael did not tell Kyle where he was going, but in the past, Michael had mentioned that he had a cousin or something like that that lived out of town, and Kyle couldn't remember off the top of his head where it was.

54:34 He would be able to recount that shortly after, but in that moment he couldn't think of it. But his guest was that that is where Mike probably went. He doesn't have any money all, he doesn't have a way to get out of town. He can't buy a flight, so that was his guess. So police were now jumping on determining who was Mike's cousin, And now we've got to go get our hands on this rapist of a young girl now turned murderer. He is dangerous. We know that he wants to have more bodies under his belt. He's made that very clear. He wants eight. That was his number, and so time was of the essence and tracking him down became priority number one. In the meantime, though, there was a really really sad thing that had to happen.

55:14 Police had to go and they had to give Seth's parents this news that they think they might know what happened to their son. The police obviously believed he was dead at this point. They had no proof of it in that moment, but that is seemingly going to be correct because Seth hadn't made any contact with them with the parents and they were continuing to search for him to no avail. So two days after Seth had been missing, his family did what they could to help keep I guess hope alive for their boy in their minds, a vigil was the best option. However, before the vigil took place, police broke the news to them that not only did they believe Seth was murdered, but also the shock that he may have been burned, he may not be in one piece he may, we don't know what has happened.

56:10 And then to add to those two layers of absolute terror and shock, they also had to break the news that it could have been a former friend that was involved in this. I mean, it was just unbelievable. You go from your child not knowing where they are to now being murdered, now possibly burned, missing body, and a friend. How do you even swallow that information? How do you even process that information? Because as far as his parents were concerned, Seth's parents, they saw the great in their boy. You know, they remembered him as someone who liked to make people laugh. He was kind hearted, y'all, he loved animals. Sure, he had his troubles, but his dream at fifteen years old was to become a member of the UFC. He dreamed of being a UFC championship and being a fighting champion.

56:57 He spent his days four wheeling and he just two brothers and hanging out with them. And now here are his parents, Scott and Sonia, And they've got this devastating task of telling his brothers, look, not only will he not be returning home, but we don't even know if he has a body left. He might be cremated somewhere. His parents obviously needed to talk to police. More police needed to interview them, and through their grief and shock, they were still able to give a bit more insight to the recent squabbles between Seth and some other kids. And this included one or two incidents that had just recently taken place, and they specifically mentioned one where Seth was outside playing basketball at their house. Seth's parents lived by the way, just about four miles down the road from the trailer that Charlie Eely owned. They said that Seth was outside playing basketball, some kids had come walking by or driving by, whatever, and an argument had ensued that are argument got so bad that Seth was screaming, get the fuck out of here, get the hell off of my property. You need to leave, and when his parents are like, dude, what is going on here? Seth had seen his girlfriend at that time, they hadn't broken up yet. He had seen his girlfriend holding hands and possibly kissing another boy. So this had Seth furious, and that is what had spawned and spurned all of this

58:27 arguing between Amber and Seth. That said they had seen this boy, Mike, come by and him and Seth had been yelling at one another. He was telling Seth to get the fuck off of their property. Now that my kid yelled out in response to Seth, whatever, motherfucker, something along those lines. Don't you worry about it. I got a bullet with your name on the written on it. WHOA. So that, in and of itself now was like, wait a second. This means that there had been prior talks of shooting Seth. It seemed like and this was days, if not weeks before this incident had occurred. So this is more than just coincidence. It seemed like, you know, this seemed like this my guy had just freaked out and blown up and came out and just started popping caps in this kid. But now the parents are saying no, no, no, no no. They had words, and he had even said he was gonna shoot Seth. So when asked to detail the fighting between Seth and Amber, his parents spoke mainly kindly about Amber. They said they were normal, they did normal things. You know, my son, he's a teenage boys.

59:39 Hormones were raging, he was interested in girls. He seemed to have a new girlfriend every couple of weeks. Then he started dating Amber. They would come over to the house. We cooked for her, we had dinner together, they would watch TV, they played basketball, very normal things. Of course, Mom was like, you know, I did feel like she's a little bit manipulative of him and his emotions at times. But all in all, there were no red flags. But Mom had witnessed something that was very poignant to detectives. She witnessed Amber walk by holding hands and kissing the other guy. Okay, well, do you know who that boy is? Who was that boy? And her answer was quick and quite shocking. She said, yeah, it's Mike. What. Yeah, the same Mike that's believed to have murdered your son was holding hands and kissing his girlfriend. She said, yes, that's why all the stupid shit seemed to be going on, is they were fighting over all of this. So, as you can imagine, police now wanted to have a word with Amber, and they also wanted to find Mike, who was still on the run. So while Amber was brought in and questioned about was there possibly a love triangle here, police had located Mike and they were heading his way for a surprise visit. Now, hear me out, don't groan, don't groan. There's so much more to this story that I'm gonna have to wrap it up in a part

1:01:11 two next week. And I'm telling you, at first, this seems like an open and shut case. Teenagers are impulsive, they're emotional, they're reckless, they do stupid things in order to look cool and whatever in front of others. But a possible love triangle that was never on the radar, that was never mentioned. Police were now headed into the teenage world of love triangles. But it would span much farther than hurt feelings, jealous texts, and angers that spiraled out of control. Because when investigators slowed this story down, really slowed it down, cracks began to show. A fight that supposedly just happened seemed to now be possibly a much more calculated event. The argument that witnesses described as somewhere just out of nowhere and explosive, well, now there would be a bunch more people that would be questioned, and as they were questioned, their answers all seem to be more like following a script. Next episode, police are going to crack this case wide open, and multiple families are going to be destroyed. You can count on it.

1:02:31 And the goons at the center of all of this, they are going to think that they are smarter than everyone. They think they can talk their way out of anything. But there's always a similar downfall in people like this. They always think they're street smart and they're smooth under pressure, when in reality, there's much more at play here because the whole time that they think that they're outsmarting people, honey, the reality is you're just underestimating them. A