Deadly Prank: The Murder of Paul Harris
On an ordinary night in Billings, Montana, 33-year-old Paul Harris was enjoying a drink at a local bar when a lighthearted prank involving a bicycle spiraled out of control. What started as harmless fun between acquaintances triggered explosive rage in Ezdeth Highley. She waited outside in the darkness and stabbed Paul three times, killing him in an instant. Kelly Jennings uncovers every chilling detail: the seemingly innocent joke that ignited the violence, the troubled background of the perpetrator, the devastating toll on Paul’s family and friends, and the shocking courtroom outcome that left many questioning justice.
Timestamps
06:49 Tension in the Bar
10:18 The Prank Gone Wrong
17:22 The Aftermath of Violence
19:30 Understanding the Criminal
22:01 The Cycle of Crime
29:34 Consequences of Release
34:44 Life After the Murder
36:54 Transformation or Manipulation?
0:06 Welcome to Unspeakable, a true crime podcast. Or I tell stories of real crimes with real victims whose cases are so shocking that many are left wondering how is this even real? I use my experiences in law enforcement corrections, and combined with my years as a criminal justice educator, dig deep into complex cases of evil acts, some so evil many feel they are unspeakable. Warning Unspeakable as intended for mature audiences. If you are easily offended, then I'm not your girl. Listening discretion is advised. Hey, y'all, it's kJ You're back with another episode of Unspeakable. If you have been listening to this show and you're up to date on episodes, then that is that's a cool thing because that means that the last episode you heard was about Daniel Marsh who murdered mister Chip and Miss Claudia.
1:17 And the reason I'm bringing this up again is because you know, he was trying to claim that he was rehabilitated, and that came only whenever a new law passed and he realized that there was a new opportunity for him to be released if you know, he was rehabilitated, and so that jump started him into pretending basically that he was. And I do hope that you learn some things whenever I'm covering these cases, not just true crime fan just because of the story, but I hope that I can teach you a thing or two along the way. I hope it opened your eyes to the manipulation attempts by many offenders, and how important it is that we look at the psychology of someone who killed and we really invest our time into understanding who these people are. On some level, even if it's just the fact that we can understand them, we cannot we cannot empathize, we cannot sympathize, we cannot understand how someone could do the things that they did. But at least when the games are played by these people and they're playing chess from behind bars, that you realize the reason that I'm that I'm stressing the importance of the victims that are behind all of this, and and my I'm tipping my hat, you know, to Sarah Rice for speaking with me, and and for being upfront and and honest and very vulnerable that her life was greatly affected by what happened after the conviction, and it still still is today. The people who are left
2:47 behind the loved ones go through so much, and a lot of people don't realize it. They think that after the trial, when the coverage wanes and it kind of fades off in the public eye, that it's gone and it's over with, and it's absolutely not over with. As more time passes, more people forget or it fades all the horrors that are inflicted, because you know, time goes by, and it goes by slowly for some while others it's just the blink of an eye. Well, this case is probably going to fall into that same category. So to that point, I want you all to come with me to Missoula, Montana. Now we're going to go back into nineteen ninety nine to start and to get yourself situated with that time. Let's let's talk about some big moments that you may or may not remember from nineteen ninety nine so that you can really put yourself in that era. Okay, The Sopranos made its debut on HBO in January of that year. In April, just a few months later, the Columbine High School massacre would leave everybody just stunned and in shock. It was all over the news and then just when we're gripping with that July would come around.
4:08 Some people may not know this one, but some may. But in July of ninety nine, the electric chair was used for the very last time in Florida when Alan Lee Davis was executed. So some big things happened in the US during this timeframe, but it was a year full of ups and downs, you know, there were some good things that happened too. And that was the same year that thirty three year old Paul Harris found himself grinning ear to ear And it was October whenever. He just was smiling so big. He had a lot to be happy about to y'all, because he had just become a brand new father. But not just a one baby.
4:56 He had gotten two. That is right, He had two brand new baby girls that he lived for. This was a guy that was built to be a daddy and he loved these two girls. Now, while he and his girlfriend Tracy had not yet tied the knot, they had been dating for two years, they were very very much committed to one another. And now I mean they were just over the moon. They both. These babies brought them such joy. Everyone knows that twins make it that much more special, and this was the beginning of something amazing. And life was good. Do you hear me? Just so good? And looking at Paul in some ways, he had kind of a Morgan Wallen quality to him. To give you a little visual. He had a mustache, a wavy hair, easygoing and fun dude. And Paul was someone that just loved a good laugh. I'm talking about someone who just loved a good laugh. If he wasn't smiling at life in general or picking on his sister, then he got a huge chuckle out of practical jokes. That was his jam.
6:05 He thought that that was just the best. And he was a great brother. He was loved very very much by his family, especially his sister Leslie, and the bond that they had while growing up was one that you would really look at, like how it's romanticized in movies, the brother and the sister who may have fought, yet they always had each other's back. So on the evening of the night before Thanksgiving, Paul was going to spend some time at a local watering hole, hanging out and relaxing with friends before the next day's celebration, sure to be full of good food and giving thanks and just all the joys that the holidays bring, and then it would officially become Christmas season, and you just know that Paul and Tracy were gonna go nuts. They were gonna go buy gifts for those two baby Girlsays were going to be in full swing, and it was just a wonderful, wonderful time. Now in the bar where Paul was hanging out, the music was playing and the patrons were milling around.
7:12 You could hear the crack of the pool balls hitting one another on the pool tables. There's just the hum of people chatting and smoking and laughing and just having a good time, and everything in the place was chill. The vibe one point, so the door opened and in walked a guy known in town and already was an acquaintance of Paul. This guy's name was Michael, and Michael was known to ride his bike for transportation. So, in typical fashion, as Michael walked into the bar, he was rolling his bike beside him and then he rested it up against the wall right there on the side of the bar. So Paul looked up. He gave a nod to Michael, who then approached him and was like, hey, man, what's going on and not much, just a little bit of chit chat. And then he said, look, would you mind helping me keep an eye on my bike because I want to go over there and play some pool, but I'm gonna leave the bike inside. Paul's like, yeah, man, no problem whatever, And so he's gonna help watch the bike, and then Michael walks over and it's gonna start up some friendly competition with the others on the pool table, and who knows, maybe he could even shark up some money in the process. Maybe it was his day to make some money. So the bartender was doing his thing, pouring drinks. Everyone's having a good time until the bartender happened to look over and there was a tip jar that was kept right there on the counter, and that tip jar had money in it because the night had been rolling and now that tip jar was empty. So
8:47 I have no way of knowing how much money was in that jar, but I mean, it could have been anything from twenty bucks to two hundred. But regardless, that's how the bartender really made his money. I mean, he was very upset about the whole thing. You just don't steal tips. We all know that. So while he was trying to determine who may have taken the cash. At some point, Michael was believed to have been the person that was nearest to the jar or the bar whenever it was last seen, and so it was kind of believed that he may have been the one who took the cash, and the bartender was not gonna let this slide, so he came from behind the bar. He approached Michael and accused him basically of taking the money, and he said, I want the money back. This is not cool. That's how I make my living. Well, Michael, as you can guess, got pissed and he said, look, I didn't take your money.
9:39 I didn't touch that jar. I didn't take the cash. And if you ever come up to me and you're gonna accuse me of something, you better make damn sure that you have your information straight. And to give you a little more information on Michael, I mean, he was rough around the edges. He was not someone who would cower to any accusation whatsoever. He just wasn't that personality. Growing up. He came from a life that was less than ideal that you know, didn't know his dad type situation. Michael was already an alcoholic. He was not above fighting for sure, and so he was pissed and he let everybody know he was pissed that he had been accused, and he denied it, flagrantly denied that he had taken any of that cash, and he went back to playing pool. Well, a little more time passed and the bartender came up and approached him again. So Michael's like, you know, with the fuck now he's mad about it, you know, blah blah blah blah blah. But this time the bartender actually was not in accusation mode. It was actually quite the opposite.
10:44 The bartender in that time that had passed, realized he had made a huge mistake, and with his head down, hat in hand, as they would say, he approached Michael man to man and he said, look, man, I just want to apologize. I need to apologize to you. The person who took the cash has been found. He admitted to taking the money, and I want to say that I am sorry. I'm sorry that I accused you, and I would like to just address you, Manda Man and say I'm sorry I was wrong. Well, Michael was still really really agitated, and although the apology was given and it was genuine. It did not help Michael's mood much.
11:30 He did not improve at all. And the more he thought about it, the matter he got. And he was drinking and he was playing pool, and he just would not necessarily accept that apology for what it was. In the meantime, Paul was still in the bar, and he was oblivious to any of that that was going on, okay, and he hadn't been a part of it, so he was kind of oblivious, and he was in the midst of setting up to pull a prank on Michael. Yes, he had agreed that he would watch Michael's bike, but he thought, oh, man, wouldn't it be funny if the bike disappeared and no one knew where it went, right, And so all the buddies that are standing there start chuckling, And so Paul and another buddy snuck the bike out of the door while Michael was playing pool, and they were chuckling and laughing, and they went and they took the bike and they put it in the back of that friend's truck outside. And the plan was that whenever Michael went to look for it, they were gonna all get played dumb and say, oh my God, what happened to the bike? We don't know what happened before, you know, busting out, laughing and giving the bike back. It was just one of those practical jokes, right. They once the bike was in the truck, they all went back to acting normal. They hurried up, got back inside, acted normal, and they just waited for the moment to strike because it was going to be freaking hilarious. All right. So some more time passed and everybody's partying, drinking and having a good time, and eventually Michael looked up and he noticed,
13:03 oh shit, my bike's gone. So he went up to find Paul and he was like, bro, I thought you were gonna help me watch my bike. You said you were going to watch it. And he kind of slapped Paul on the shoulder when he did that. Hey man, you said that you were gonna you were gonna watch my bike. Well, Michael, Paul tells Michael, look, I didn't know, you know, I don't I don't know where your bike went. Because he's playing along with the prank. And rather than Michael freaking out and them going outside to find the bike and then ha ha ha and laughing about it, it shifted into something much more tense than what was expected. Now, I have nothing to base this on. What I'm gonna say.
13:54 Accept my opinion, but it's based on, you know, everything I know about what's going on in the moment. But Michael's approach to things seemed to have made it not fun almost instantly, like one of those things where it was meant to be fun. But the tone that Michael took wasn't like an innocent like, oh my god, where's my bike where they could laugh and joke. It was more like aggressive and pissed off, where another guy would kind of cock his head to the side and be like, what the hell, bro Like, you know, so I don't. I got the feeling that it turned almost into a pissing contest from the jump, rather than it getting to be the comical thing that it was intended to be. So Michael said that the bartender said they needed to take it outside. Nobody else has really said that either way, whether they went outside to go look for the bike or whether the bartender told him to leave. Either way, they ended up outside, so Paul opened the door and the two of them walked outside and went across the street.
14:51 Most likely towards the truck to go get the bike from the truck. But Paul would never even make it too the truck to be able to say anything, because the very same man who was indignant to the fact that he was being accused of stealing cash you know a little while before, pulled out a knife and attacked his friend Paul before he even knew what was happening. Before Paul even knew that he was in a fight, Michael pulled out a knife and jugged Paul three times, Boom boom boom with the knife, and Paul immediately fell to the ground. And if anyone knows anything about being stabbed, you should never ever remove the knife or the object that has impaled you. But Michael didn't care. Michael was in a full blown rage. He stabbed as hard as he could, pulled out, stabbed as hard as he could, pulled out, stabbed as hard as he could, pulled out, all in a matter of seconds. So by doing this multiple times and then removing the blade, the damage that was done to Paul's abdomen was catastrophic. The bleeding would go uncontrolled as there was no one around to give immediate aid. In that exact moment, and any aid of any purposeful help wasn't available. And the other issue is that while alcohol and knives certainly don't mix, I can only assume that Paul had been drinking and celebrating while
16:22 he was inside of the bar. And we all know that alcohol in your system will thin your blood and it will reduce your clotting abilities. And so this meant that in an instant, Paul's chances of survival would have been lowered even more from the start. So Michael's pissed attacks Paul, who has no clue that this is coming. And when Paul collapses to the ground, Michael then turns and flees the scene, takes off running on foot gone So as Michael ran, Paul was laying on the ground in immense pain. But that wouldn't last long because someone would find Paul and they would call for an ambulance, which rushed to the scene. But by the time the ambulance got there, it was just of no use because Paul was already dead. He was well beyond any help when they arrived. He had lay there in the dark and bled to death on the street side. In an instant, in an absolute instant, two little girls had no daddy.
17:31 They were still infants, and the chance to know him was now gone. Tracy didn't know it yet, but she was now the single mother of twins. And for what for what? How did we escalate this quickly in this podcast? That is what happened in this real life situation that quick. Paul was a good guy, y'all, and because he went to go play a prank, he was dead. Make that make sense. It's unbelievable. It's not one of those cases where two drug dealers, you know, we're shooting it out, or a bad guy, you know, does something to another bat.
18:15 I mean, this is a good guy dead, just over a prank. And it didn't take long for police to id who was responsible for the stabbing and murder of Paul Harris, because everyone in the bar knew that there had been tension all night surrounding Michael highly for a multitude of situations. So he was tracked down by the very next day and he was arrested, and rightfully so, he was charged with first degree murder and he sat in jail awaiting his trial. So right now you're like, well, wow, Kelly, that was a really short and sweet episode. We'll hold your horses here, because you know that there's going to be more. You know there's going to be more. There's no wild story here as to Michael Higley's conviction, okay, but it's after his conviction where this story becomes another sick reminder that the victims lose the spotlight and the killers will take over. I have followed up with mister Chip and Missus Claudia's murders with this case for a reason.
19:23 I want you to see this happen over and over because dead doesn't mean irrelevant. It should never mean irrelevant. Just because the victims are dead doesn't mean that they are now irrelevant. But here we go again. So looking into the history of Michael Highley, it turns out that he had actually been a hothead for a very very long time. Likely his entire life would be very accurate. He loved to drink, he loved to fight, and he really liked to do things that were against the rules. And this is all per his own admission, by the way, when he was a kid, when he was young, I think starting at like nine years old, he was drinking.
20:05 He got a little bit older, and you know the young punk teenager phase and he started running with the local gangs. He was constantly in trouble. So it makes you wonder, it really should make you wonder, where was the accountability at that point, at that point, what was going on? Because between the ages of fifteen and nineteen years old, excuse me, fifteen and twenty nine years old, he was arrested multiple times for drugs, weapons possession, and then as he got older, parole violations. So just for example here, when he was a teenager, he stole his stepdad's rifles that he had and he sold them. Why did he do that, Well, he wanted the cash that he could get so he could buy drugs, and because he just wanted to get even with a stepdad because he was mad at him, so he took what he loved and sold it off. Now, those guns were eventually turned into police and Michael was arrested for that. But even late into his twenties, I mean, he was still always in trouble. Because let's make common sense here. If you have parole violations, then you must have been on parole, which means you've already been in serious trouble prior to this murder of Paul Harris. So basically My point here is that this guy was in trouble from the jump.
21:26 Yet this is one of those revolving door criminals in and out of the system with no real consequences, at least at the level of stupidity that we are dealing here with Michael Highly. So, even when he was in jail and eventually would end up in prison, I want you to know, he continued to use drugs behind bars with no desire to get sober or to turn his life around. So it also turns out that right before the stabbing murder of Paul Harris, Michael Highly was just released from prison. He was twenty nine years old when in early nineteen ninety nine he was approved to be released by a parole board. When you are released by a parole board, guys, there are conditions that are non negotiable that you must comply with. If an offender breaks those rules, then there's going to be a revocation of their release opportunity, and that's documented, okay, and arrest warrant is issued and then they have to return to custody for the remainder of their sentence. That's how parole works.
22:35 Those rules and those conditions are stated in writing and they are part of an agreement which is signed by the parole lea. You cannot feign that you didn't know, okay, the rules and the regulations, and one of Michael's was no drinking whatsoever and no bars. That was a rule, a conditional release based on following that one rule, we will let you out of prison. But obviously Michael didn't give a shit what conditional release he was under, as evidenced by this very case. A parolee too, I want to give you some insight to parole. A parole is also supposed to pay a supervisory fee each month when they are under supervision. And fun fact about that. So that's all great when people say, oh, well, yeah they're paying a fee, you know, they're paying for their own supervision when they're out on parole. Fun fact here, the parole or the committees that are in place may vary state to state who decides this, but they can choose to reduce or waive that fee all together. I mean, they can suspend the monthly payment all together if they feel like it's going to cause the parole significant financial hardship.
23:49 And it makes me wonder, I wonder, I wonder if Paul's family and his now two fatherless children, if they faced any financial hardships that went unnoticed since his death, because I'm sure those funeral fees weren't waived, and after all, there is no committee for victims left behind where they're gonna, you know, offset any hardships that these children may face or their family may face. But the parole is sure does get that benefit. If it's seen that he should get that, he should have been assigned a parole officer who he had open and constant communication with, with one of the main parole revocation discussions being that he should have no drug use, no alcohol use, no using of weapons, blah blah blah blah blah. But yet he was out free from prison on parole for four months, only four months before he murdered Paul Harris. So really think about that.
24:56 He was approved for early release and murdered someone within four months. So there is an issue here. Wherever you want to place the blame, there is an issue here. Okay. So when you're checking in with a parole officer these you know the frequency and whether the offender is considered high risk, all of that kind of stuff that's a lot is going to go into how often they're going to check in with their parole officer. So I don't have the documents in Michael Highley's plan for whenever he was released, but I can tell you this, back in the nineties, once a month wasn't uncommon. So this would mean that he would have possibly only seen his parole officer Max three times before he went and he murdered someone.
25:44 So why was Michael in prison in the first place that he had to be parolled out? Well, due to the age of this story that I'm starting with, to tell you is going to be difficult because documentation is limited. However, I want to give you some backstory according to his own mother. Okay, whenever Michael Highley was just a teenager, he was completely ungovernable and no matter what efforts his own mother put into trying to turn him around, no matter what she did, he did whatever he wanted. He did not listen. He ran free and crazy, and she always was concerned about him because she knew about his temper.
26:29 All right. He would get mad and then do something completely out of pocket and never even think before he did it. That's who Michael Higley was. He would rage, and then he would flash out does that sound like someone who should be granted parole or does that sound like somebody who's able to put on a good show. I'm going to let you, the listener decide either way. Whenever he was a teenager, he got into trouble with a drug dealer who ended up chasing him back to his house, so Michael ran home, ran into the house, he grabbed his sister's rifle, pointed the rifle out of the window, and shot the drug dealer through the window.
27:14 So the dealer ended up living in this situation, and Michael was charged, but his family then open moved from Chicago to Montana, and Michael was never locked up for that shooting. Can you right now, can you ever imagine shooting someone and nothing happening to you, no follow up, even if it was a justifiable shooting, which in this case, I don't know. Man' you're you stole from a drug dealer. Looks like you're both kind of in the wrong here. Okay, today we have a felony or a shooting that happens during the commission of a felony, and that's a different charge. I know, we didn't necessarily have it back then, but like, this isn't like some just innocent guy defending his homestead. No, he was acting up and he shot somebody, and just because he moved away, nothing really happened to him. So they moved, and the reason they moved is that his mom was trying to get him out of that environment.
28:09 But no matter what they did, Michael continued not to listen. He just changed locations with her. So she ended up taking him to doctors for his anger issues, and the doctors would give advice and talk through what we need to do, but he never listened to any advice from the doctors. He refused to listen. So the mom was unable to help him no matter what she tried, and it finally came to a point where she just realized that she couldn't help him anymore. He was old enough that this is not something that it's out of her hands, basically, So when his mother found out now that Michael had gotten out of prison and then turned around and murdered Paul Harris, all she could really do at that point was just shake her head. She's like, I taught him all of the right things. I tried to impress on him you needed to learn to walk away being a hot head. Don't let it take over. I tried to make him stop drinking. I did not want him using drugs.
29:06 I tried to be involved in his life, but he just didn't care. And that makes you just think. You know, when someone's own mother recognizes that their kid is a bad seed, and then he's able to make it out on parole from a previous conviction and then go murder somebody else, there's a problem. We cannot be soft on crime like this. We cannot be soft on these people. They're not going to be soft on us. Do we not see this over and over and over again. So in May of two thousand, Michael Highly pled guilty to deliberate homicide and he was sentenced a few months later on August tenth of two thousand and four, the murder of Paul Harris. Now here's the kicker. The judge that would preside over Michael highly sentencing was the same judge that Michael had been in front of in multiple other cases that he had been charged with in the prior six years before the stabbing of Paul Harris. Tell me you are not a massive issue to society when the judge knows you by name. The only judges that know me by name are ones that I'm friends with, never because I went before them that many times. Michael had previous charges for burglary, possession of a deadly weapon, and those repeated parole violations, yet he never went back to
30:39 prison for those. The consensus amongst the judges, and to an extent I agree here, is that prison should be a last resort. Okay, I get that we shouldn't be throwing people in prison for running stop signs. We shouldn't be throwing teenagers in prison and just getting rid of them because you know they're fistfighting at the high schools or whatever. Okay, but hopefully you're seeing that this is a different situation. How many chances? How many chances does a person get before they then turn around and murder someone? In this case and unfortunately in many others, the answer is a lot. There's consistency here that the benefit of the doubt is continued to be given to offenders who escalate and escalate and then kill people. Helly shot somebody before.
31:31 So while data differs from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, I want to give you a little bit of information here. I want you to be an educated listener, okay, and just give you a little bit of information to work with as we talk through this case. Research into prison populations consistently shows that over ninety percent of prisoners, including those that are serving time for violent crimes, not just like you know, possession of a pipe or something, they are repeat criminals. A majority of them are repeat criminals. And I know metrics differ in data collection, but I have heard people say that violent offenders, like those who murder people, often they're going to say, oh, well, they don't murder again. Usually, you know, it's just this one time instance. Blah blah blah blah blah. And if they're released, if they're released, that they're you know, they're not gonna they're not going to commit another murder or they're not going to continue to do this blah blah blah. But I'm here to tell you something. Everything in this lifetime is relative. Everything is relative. If someone murdered somebody at thirty years old and then they went to prison for forty years, let's do some basic math. How old are they when they get out, because the answer is going to be seventy they're not gangbanging anymore. It's seventy. The value in their correction was in the time they spent behind bars and they got old. The value is no in being locked up.
33:01 The value is in how long they were locked up. You can't just trust the data on face value when people say, oh, they're not likely to commit again if they even if it's a nonviolent crime. Let's say it's just you know, something bad. You know, they're selling drugs at a mass quantity or something like that, and then they go to prison for a long time and then they get out and then the data shows, oh, they didn't reoffend. Well you have to look at more than that. How old are they? You know what I'm saying, like not everything is black and white. So either way, the judge here, this judge is Judge Larsen was the name. The judge knew at this point. Look, someone's dead this end. It's game over for you, dude, It is game over.
33:42 But the sentence that was handed down was sixty years in prison, and here's the keyword with with the possibility of parole after fifteen years. So the requirement was that he had to complete mental health counseling programs. Mental health programs had to complete them as well as drug dependency courses, so there would need to be proof basically that he was working on personal growth. Now, speaking on personal growth, okay, this would mean that dead Paul Harris's kids wouldn't even be eighteen years old. They would not have even had their own personal growth to the age of eighteen, and Michael highly could potentially be out walking the streets again. Possibly.
34:33 That is sick to me. This is a lot for a family to have to live with knowing that the trial was just the beginning. Sentencing of Paul's killer was going to now leave them in a continuous state of what ifs in terms of his relief. Just the sentencing alone sixty years sounds like a lot, but he has the possibility of parole after fifteen years. So the tenancying of Paul's killer was now going to leave them in a continuous state of what ifs in terms of his release. So as all of this is taking place, another blow to the family of Paul would be dealt. And you know his sister. I mentioned her, Leslie. She was a young single mother of her own child by this point and she was now facing another huge life altering issue as a result of this case. Tracy, that was Paul's girlfriend at the time and the mother of the twins, she did not handle his death well. She didn't handle it well. Not everybody has the ability to chin up, chest out and power through and that's okay. This was devastating to her. She went downhill very quickly, very very quickly. Emotionally, she was destroyed and she not pull herself out of the depths of despair. So Tracy and Paul's twin girls
36:07 ended up in foster care. She was not able to mother, and damn it, I'm gonna stand up right now and say I have a heart right here. This woman's life was destroyed in an instant. She lost the love of her life, the father of her children. So I'm not gonna judge her here. The kids ended up in foster care, whatever the case. And now Paul's family was struggling because they wanted to make sure that the twins would be placed back within their family. They're now fighting two fronts here. We want Paul's kids and we need to know that this guy's not going to get out again, and that my brother's life mattered, and it mattered more than fifteen years in prison, that's nothing. Both of those little girls were also now old enough to know and realize that they're mama wasn't there, and they were really struggling without their family. The trauma here was unending, absolutely unending. So Michael, either way, he was sentenced, and he was sent behind bars, and years would pass. Okay, those years, as most of us would hope, should have been spent working on himself making progress. We can't just say we don't hope people progress behind bars. I think that'd be disingenuous. I do want people to get better. I do want them to make a difference in their own lives. At least the death of Paul would result in something good, you know, in a weird way. At least somebody benefited from it.
37:40 And I don't even want to say it like that. That sounds horrible, But we want good to prevail in some fashion, right, whatever it may be. But by twenty sixteen, the only real change that Michael Highly had made was his emphatic announcement that he was now transender. That was his big announcement, eighteen years after he stabbed Paul Harris to death over a bicycle prank. He wanted the world to know that he was now a new person and that he was in the process of transitioning to be a female. So at first you're like, okay, whatever, whoopedy shit.
38:23 But there is more to this than meets the eye, because it is tied to a court decision in Indiana, and that decision would allow convicted murderers to in Indiana at least okay, it would allow convicted murderers there to receive a taxpayer funded sex change surgery. And it all stems from a lawsuit that was filed by an inmate who goes by Autumn Cordellion, who is so being fifty five years in a state prison for the strangulation of an eleven month old. We can't overlook this. I don't care what side of the aisle you're on about transgender issue.
39:14 That is not the point here. My point is that this guy fifty five years is the sentence he strangled an eleven month old baby. The baby didn't even make it to its first birthday, and yet the courts are consumed with his sexuality. His argument is that basically it was a violation of the Eighth Amendment, Cruel and Unusual Punishment Amendment to deny him gender affirming surgery. And like I said, I'm not getting up in the politics of sex changes. That is irrelevant to me right now. What I will get into is the fact that the victims in these cases, they were never afforded their right against cruel and unusual punishment. This is ludicrous, absolutely ludicrous. I don't care what type of social warrior you may be think about these victims. Paul is dead, Paul is dead, yet we should entertain the sexual identity of his killer.
40:31 An eleven month old baby who couldn't even talk was strangled to death. Yet we the people should not only care, but fund the sexual identity of the child's killer. We should care what he wants sexually. I find that absolutely completely offensive and in direct contempt of what the purpose of prison is. Prison is for punishment, and it's for time to be spent reconciling what you have done to others. And in both of these cases I've mentioned to you here, it was taking a life. That is what it all boils down to. But instead these killers have spent their time thinking about me. What's happening to me? So Michael highly now claims that the only reason he killed Paul was because of a gender identity issue. He was ashamed of who he was and that was what made him angry.
41:41 It wasn't the alcohol that night that he was consuming in direct violation of his parole conditions. It wasn't because of the drinking and the anger issues. No, it's because he wanted to be a woman. That's why he killed Paul highly Now, mind you, he was first eligible for parole in twenty eleven, and in the time that he spent in prison up to twenty eleven for starters, he failed to show any remorse for what he had done. He actually almost justifies murdering Paul Harris as he's justifying it as part of his reaction to his own internal struggles.
42:29 I find it insanity that Paul's name would even be tied to this argument. Paul had nothing to do with any of that. Paul was playing a prank on a bicycle, you know, or with a bicycle. How the hell are these two things even put in the same story. They're two different things. Paul was murdered because a drunk in a bar, which was against parole violations, got mad over a joke. This guy, you know, Paul's being played. His anger issues took over. He chose to carry a weapon which was also in direct contempt and violation of the parole rules, which he then took out and used to stab Paul to death. Anyone willing to entertain anything else in this case as to what happened as a cause is literally, in my opinion, spatting on the grave of Paul Harris. You are spatting on him. This seems to me like a contrived attempt at a pity of you know, he wants to get people's pity, and he's using a socially hot topic to try and gain sympathy, as if Michael has had some type of life altering enlightenment that sweeps away all of the bad that he has done and the quote unquote knew him should should shine through all of that. So what was his new name choice? Okay,
44:00 let's let's just let's just assume he's made these sweeping changes. Let's believe him. Okay, just for shits and giggles. What is his new name choice? The new name choice, with this new non threatening, non dangerous, enlightened persona, he's now got what's the name. I'm glad you asked, because the name is as Death. How do you spell that? I'm I know right now, you're like, wait, what how do you spell that? Kelly? Oh, it's it's simple to remember easy death, easy death, kind of kind of like a Paul's was. I guess how how easy it was to murder Paul? Easy? It was an easy death. It's just appalling to even humor the idea. But but that's it.
44:53 His new name is as Death spelled easy death. So I googled as Death because I I was like, there's got to be something to this. Why what a weird name. He didn't pick Molly or Sarah or something like that. Now he picked as Death, something very strange. So I googled it to figure out what is this name about? And I found that this is an anime character? Okay, And all of these characters have personas of their own, and they have like a premise to them, correct, So I thought that I would give you the premise of the as Death character. She's a sadist. She's a massive manipulator and a violence fiend who believes that the weak should be purged and deserve no empathy. As Death is a sadistic, barbarious, and bloodthirsty woman who lacks empathy for people whom she deems weak, despite appearing to care about those working underneath her. Ever since, she is motivated by her father's philosophy, which is the strong survive and the weak perish. She has gone through torturous activities that involve putting her enemies through great pain, both physically and emotionally.
46:14 She has no qualms about her ruthlessness and battle or killing innocent people to get what she wants, and rationalizes her behavior with her father's old creed. You can look it up yourself if you don't believe me. So as Paul remains dead and his daughters without a father, this is the greatest achievement and change that his killer has made in all of these years. No apologies, no regrets, just a new name. How would you feel if that was your brother? I'm all about putting yourself in somebody's shoes.
47:00 The shoes I want to put on are the victims in this case. How would you feel if that was your brother? The courts just arguing over whether to give his killer hormones and whether his killer should get surgery, and whatever else. He feels like he needs to be his true self all the while, Paul will never get to be himself ever again. Growing up, and I know this story is not about me, but I just have to say this. Growing up, my mama instilled something in me, and it was this statement. She told me, Kelly, always be nice to people because they might be angels in disguise.
47:43 And as an adult now, as an adult with my own decision making choices and I can do whatever the hell I want, I have chosen to continue with this thought process. I will be kind to people. I do believe in loving people and treating everyone with kindness, even the people that I don't agree with, even people on different spectrums of whatever situation we're talking about. Loving people comes just it's humanity, It's natural right. But Michael highly as an adult, what thought process does he follow? Well, I didn't get to talk to Michael, but what I did do was I looked up what is as Death?
48:31 The character what is her most famous quote? And this is what it is? As Death says, I don't understand the feelings of the weak. The law of the world is survival of the fittest. It's how the weak are weeded out. It just means those people that died were too weak. It's only natural for the week to perish. I'm not impressed, guys. I do not feel sympathy at all from Michael Highley. If he suffered in his life, so have tons of other people. And to that point, most people with gender identity issues don't commit murder. They don't hurt other people as a response to it. They are good people. This whole story, and the reason I brought it to you is because it's just another control tactic by Michael Highley to go against the grain. And in an interview that Michael Higley did, he said, and this is a direct quote, he said, I'm not quite as violent as I used to be. Not quite. You're not quite as violent as you used to be. So you fall right underneath the violence level of murdering because you're a murderer. You're not quite a murderer anymore, because that's just not impressive to me. The majority of the
50:02 people on the planet aren't murderers. And we don't use that as a bragging point either. We're decent, good people. We just act normal. We don't kill people. So as of right now, Michael Highley has been denied parole six times and he remains incarcerated at the Montana State Prison in Deer Lodge for the murder of Paul Harris. That's a good thing. Michael was unruly. Michael was an alcoholic and a drug addict. Michael shot a drug dealer. Michael was in and out of prison and ignoring his rules of parole. Michael stabbed and murdered Paul Harris. But now Michael wants a clean slate with a new name and a polished story of rebirth. But here's the thing, guys, Accountability doesn't get amnesia just because you updated your identity like a damn Facebook profile. Real change leaves evidence. It shows up in actions, in repair, and in taking actual accountability.
51:19 None of that is evident. There is no ownership, there is no remorse. There is no weight carried on his shoulders for the incredible harm that was done. Just a radical claim of change and the hope that everyone's too distracted by his new change to remember about Paul. But I remember Paul, I remember the callousness shown, and I remember you, Michael Highley running away and letting him die in the road. You can call it transformation. You can call it enlightenment, you can call it whatever the hell you want. But it's giving Halloween costume. It's cheap, temporary, and nobody believes that it's real m
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
Castro
RSS Feed